Posts

Over Hans Schnitzler, statistiek en grote voeten

(Note: my apologies for this Dutch entry) In een opiniestuk in De Volkskrant op 16/07/2012 (zie http://www.volkskrant.nl/vk/nl/3184/opinie/article/detail/3286922/2012/07/16/Wantrouw-statistieken-negeer-peilingen.dhtml ) houdt de filosoof Hans Schnitzler ons voor dat we de statisticus moeten wantrouwen en de opiniepeiler negeren. Het is zijn goed recht om dat te doen. Er zijn, vooral in Nederland, de laatste tijd nogal wat persberichten verschenen rond opiniepeilingen die inderdaad de wenkbrauwen doen fronsen. Als Schnitzler ijvert voor grotere steekproeven en meer zorg voor representativiteit dan zal hij bij heel wat statistici en opiniepeilers op bijval kunnen rekenen. Meer zelfs, uitgerekend uit de hoek van opiniepeilers, en marktonderzoekers in het algemeen, is er een vraag om met meer zorg en nuance over onderzoek te rapporteren in de populaire pers. Als er al sprake is van een illusie van voorspelbaarheid dan wordt die illusie meer gevoed door de verslaggeving rond bepaalde o...

Eerie similarity: Stockmarket predicts Germany-Greece soccer game result!

Image
Forget Paul the Octopus, Chanakya the Fish, and all other football predicting animals. It appears that the stock market can be used to predict the outcome of  football matches!  Now that the stock markets are not doing so well, at least we can use them to make a few bucks on football betting sites. Take last weekend's game, for instance, when Germany played Greece. It turns out that the score evolution of this game followed a very similar pattern than the German Greek spread from half March to half June 2012. The pattern is obvious in the graph below. The correlation between the two series is an impressive 93%. The attentive reader will notice that there is a gap between the 45 and 60 minutes marks. Indeed the stock markets predicted that the third and fourth German goals would have been scored earlier. Specialists are investigating whether this has to do with the break after the first half . But, other than that small gap, the fit between the two lines is very close. These...

Uplace and the binomial distribution

Image
Currently there is a debate in Belgium about the construction of Uplace, a huge shopping mall on the outskirts of Brussels. A marketing professor of the Vlerick School, Gino Van Ossel, did a survey which showed that, contrary to popular believe, quite a big group was actually in favor rather than opposing the plans. So far so good, but the professor's methodology was questioned in the media. The arguments used against the survey findings were not very strong, I believe, and I will not discuss them here. However, a part of the reasoning used by Gino Van Ossel looked rather odd to me and made me think about a more general problem that I would like to discuss here. Those of you who understand Dutch can find all the details on www.marketingblog.vlerick.com . In short, he found that in a sample of 654, representing the total Belgium, 33% was in favor, while in the region where the shopping mall would located, with a sample of 182, 46% were in favor. This was against the popular believ...

Blinded by the client

Don't you hate it when people are pestering you with client focus? These days everybody in an organisation should be focused on the client, it seems. I'm not sure this is always a healthy situation. As a matter of fact, I'm writing these words on an airplane heading to Dublin. I hope and I pray that the pilot is not focused on the client, but rather on his airplane dashboard. Sure, we all know that organizations should be client focused if they want to survive, but that does not mean that all members of the organization should be client focused all of the time. It seems to be the business equivalent of the Robinson effect (Robinson, W.S. (1950). "Ecological Correlations and the Behavior of Individuals". American Sociological Review 15: 351 – 357.). Based on the 1930 US census, William S. Robinson found a positive correlation between the literacy rate of a state and the percentage of inhabitants born outside the US, while at the individual level this  correlation...